The American Conservative

What you're reading

The American Conservative is a Washington-based politics and culture magazine founded in 2002 by Pat Buchanan, Scott McConnell, and Taki Theodoracopulos. It was launched explicitly as a paleoconservative and non-interventionist counter to the neoconservative direction the broader Right was taking around the Iraq War, and it has held that lane through every shift in Republican politics since. The publishing nonprofit is the American Ideas Institute.

The magazine publishes a bi-monthly print edition and a daily web operation covering foreign policy (especially restraint and anti-interventionism), trade and industrial policy, religion and culture, immigration, urbanism and place-based conservatism, and the long-running internal Right argument over what conservatism should be. Regular contributors over the years have included Rod Dreher, Daniel Larison, Andrew Bacevich, and a rotating slate of academic and policy writers. Audience is smaller than mass-market conservative outlets but disproportionately influential among think tanks, congressional staff, and the post-fusionist intellectual Right.

Ownership & funding

The American Ideas Institute (nonprofit). Funded primarily through nonprofit + reader donations.

Running on nonprofit status plus reader donations removes the pressure to chase mass-market clicks and lets the magazine cover unfashionable beats — foreign-policy restraint, anti-interventionism, place-based conservatism — that don't pay on ad-driven sites. It also frees editors to publish long-form essays and dissident-Right arguments without losing access to mainstream-conservative advertisers, because there aren't any. The trade-off: small budget, modest staff, limited original reporting. Most of the product is opinion-essay and analysis rather than shoe-leather news. Donor influence is real but diffuse — the funder base is a mix of paleoconservative individual donors and small foundations rather than a single concentrated source.

Where they land on the spectrum

nwsly's editorial team places The American Conservative at Lean Right with a factuality rating of Mostly Factual.

The American Conservative is rated Lean Right rather than Right because its conservatism is genuinely heterodox and frequently crosses partisan lines. The magazine has been one of the most consistent and earliest critics of the Iraq War, NATO expansion, US support for the Saudi war in Yemen, and military aid to both Ukraine and Israel — positions that diverge sharply from the mainstream Republican consensus. On trade and industrial policy it has argued for protectionism and tariffs since long before they were respectable on the Right. On immigration and cultural issues it sits firmly within conservative orthodoxy.

Where it breaks pattern most clearly is foreign policy and political economy, where its writers are sometimes closer to progressive critics of US empire than to Republican leadership. It has also published sharp internal-Right criticism of figures the broader conservative movement defends. Factuality lands at Mostly Factual because the magazine is essay-and-analysis-driven rather than reported-news-driven, which makes "factuality" partly about whether arguments engage seriously with their opposition (they generally do) and whether factual claims in essays are sourced and accurate (they generally are). The ceiling sits below "High" because opinion-first publications inherently mix argument and assertion in ways harder to fact-check than straight reporting.

Editorial vs news side

The American Conservative is an opinion-and-analysis magazine, not a newspaper. There is no separate news desk. The product is essays, columns, book reviews, and policy analysis written from an openly stated conservative perspective. That means the Lean Right rating applies to the whole publication; there's no straight-news section to separate out. Readers should treat every piece as argument rather than reporting, and weigh the magazine alongside reported sources on the same topics. What it offers is a heterodox conservative perspective in essay form — closer to The Atlantic's editorial structure than to The Wall Street Journal's news-versus-opinion split.

Why we include them in nwsly

Politics and culture magazine founded in 2002.

Among Lean Right sources, The American Conservative occupies a slot no other outlet does: it brings the foreign-policy-restraint, anti-interventionist, post-fusionist conservative perspective that mainstream Right outlets either ignore or actively oppose. nwsly uses it when a brief needs a conservative argument on Ukraine, Israel, China, trade, or industrial policy that diverges from the Wall Street Journal editorial line. It's also useful for tracking intra-Right intellectual debates — Trumpism vs. traditional conservatism, the religious-right realignment, urbanism on the Right — that don't show up in the daily-news outlets.

Recent nwsly briefs citing The American Conservative

Coming soon — feed from /today and /catalog will populate this section.